Chapter 12 Exercise 12.4 Question 1 Solution : Justify why the plane cannot be tiled with a regular pentagon. (Hint: read the first 3 sentences of "Think and Reflect" in the section on tiling.)
The angles of a pentagon add up to (5 − 2) × 180° = 540°. In a regular pentagon all five are equal:
In a tiling, the tiles meeting at a vertex fill the full turn: their angles add up to 360°. If only regular pentagons meet there, k of them give 108° × k.
| Number of pentagons k | Total angle 108° × k | Equal to 360°? |
|---|---|---|
| 2 | 216° | no |
| 3 | 324° | no |
| 4 | 432° | no, too large |
We would need 108k = 360, so k = 103, which is not a whole number.
There the angles must add up to 180° instead, and 108k = 180 gives k = 53, again not a whole number.
The angles at a vertex must add up to 360° (or 180° on a side), but 108° times a whole number is never 360° or 180°. So a regular pentagon cannot tile the plane.