Note: this is an open proof question. These are outlines of the key reasons.
What has to be proved
(1) No overlaps: two copies never share an interior point. (2) No gaps: every point of the plane lies in some copy. Both follow if copies fit exactly along each edge and the angles around every vertex add up to exactly 360°.
Method 1 · Half-turns about midpoints of sides
- A half-turn about the midpoint of a side maps that side onto itself, with its ends swapped, and puts the image on the other side of the side's line. So the new copy shares exactly that side with the old one, with no overlap.
- At any vertex, going around it one meets the copies obtained by repeated half-turns. Each half-turn about the midpoint of an edge at that vertex brings the next angle of the 4-gon. After four of them, all four angles appear once: 360°, so there is no gap and no overlap.
- Doing two half-turns one after the other is a translation, so the pattern repeats in the plane in two directions, and nothing is left uncovered.
Method 2 · The grid of Varignon parallelograms
The sides of the Varignon parallelogram are AC2 and BD2, that is half of the diagonal vectors u and w. Placing copies of the 4-gon on every second cell of the grid, in both directions, puts them at the positions iu + jw. These are the same positions as in Method 3, so the same reasoning applies: the copies meet only at vertices, and the gaps are filled with half-turn copies, as in Method 1.
Method 3 · Sliding along diagonals
Sliding by the diagonal vectors u = EO and w = SM gives copies at all positions iu + jw. These copies meet only at vertices, by the four parallelograms of Question 18. The gaps have the same area as the 4-gon and are half-turn copies of it, so they are filled as in Method 1.
In all three methods, copies fit along equal edges and the angles at each vertex are the four angles of the 4-gon, which add up to 360°, so there are no gaps and no overlaps.